Fair Treatment for the Women of Wales (FTWW) is a constituted third sector girls’ and women’s health and equality organisation, providing support, advice, and advocacy to women across the country. The following is submitted on behalf of our members:
i) Promote and protect the health and wellbeing of children from
pregnancy (for example through positive parenting, high
immunisation rates and tackling smoking in
pregnancy).
1) FTWW would like to draw attention to the importance of
safe-guarding and enhancing the health and well-being of women
(mothers) as an integral part of promoting and protecting the
infant.
2) One key element of this is recognising that it is women
who are most likely to be in poverty (as part-time / low-paid
workers, in relationships where they are victims of economic
violence, ie monies are kept from them by abusive partners, or
recipients of benefits for long-term mental / physical
illness).
3) It is therefore essential that health services work with
other agencies (education, employment, third sector support) so
that girls and women are empowered – and enabled - to make
positive life choices which, in turn, impact the lives of their
children.
4) It is also incumbent upon health services in Wales to
ensure that they provide (and do not prohibit) access to those
physical and mental interventions that are widely available
elsewhere and which can enable women / mothers (and their infants)
to have superior outcomes. For example, the lack of maternal mental
health services provision (both pre- and post-natal), including
designated specialist beds for those women with psychosis to stay
with their babies in their locality (for family support) is of huge
concern to our members.
5) It is widely accepted that maternal mental health
problems can have long-standing ramifications for children,
constituting an ‘adverse childhood experience’ (ACE)
which Public Health Wales is keen to avoid, recognising how more
than 4 of these can result in a massively increased chance of
ill-health and economic deprivation for that child as they grow up.
Inevitably, this costs the Welsh economy significant sums.
Therefore, early intervention, by ensuring mothers’ mental
health needs are met during and after pregnancy, is
essential.
ii) Deliver improved child health outcomes across Wales (for example prevention of obesity and the promotion of health-enhancing behaviours for every child such as eating a well balanced diet, playing actively, and having an appropriate weight and height for their age and general health)
6)Welsh
government needs to recognise that girls are less likely to engage
with traditional forms of exercise / physical education provided by
schools. To this end, it seems incumbent upon education providers
to be innovative in terms of what they offer.
7) Once again, we would draw attention to the impact of
poverty on healthy-eating and how, once again, it seems that it is
women (mothers) who need support in this regard. Further to
paragraph 1, women are more likely to be sole carers for children,
and often struggle financially to provide more expensive
‘healthy’ foods.
8) Delivering improved child health outcomes also requires
more of a focus on PSHE in schools. Too often the
‘health’ aspect is omitted from the curriculum –
and this is because, increasingly, we are expecting too much of our
teachers in terms of workload and expertise. It is not reasonable
to expect a decent PSHE syllabus to be delivered in half an hour a
week by teachers who are experts in an academic subject, rather
than various personal / health / social issues.
9) Nor is it reasonable to expect, just an example, young
girls who may be entering puberty and need advice / support to
approach a male maths teacher for help, just because he is their
form tutor and therefore the person responsible for delivering
PSHE.
10) Part of resolving this requires school nurses to be
present, full-time, in every school, and education authorities need
to be working with third sector organisations to deliver expert
knowledge in an age-appropriate way.
iii) Tackle child health inequalities, with a specific focus on child poverty and disabled children.
11)FTWW
would like to draw attention to the fact that disability
isn’t always visible. Many girls within our organisation
suffer because they aren’t ‘well’ (and often
struggle to get a diagnosis for conditions for which the symptoms
are very intimate in nature) and so struggle to attend school or
lead an active life. However, they also don’t ‘fit
in’ with conventional perceptions of disability. As such,
they experience considerable social isolation, their mental and
physical health suffers, and their long-term prospects are
negatively affected.
12) As a society we need to be much more cognisant of the
effects of ‘invisible’ disability / chronic illness,
and we also need to appreciate how girls in particular can suffer
the consequences of social taboos and prejudices pertaining to
their health. Gynaecological issues become a key focus for girls
early on in life – but they still feel prohibited from
talking about them publicly, a silence which can result in decades
long delays in recognising and dealing with problems.
13) Further to that, the cultural tendency (even within the
medical profession) to attribute girls’ physical health
problems to a psychological cause does girls (and women) a huge
disservice, resulting in poorer health outcomes, reduced economic
activity, and an increased chance of living in poverty in the
future. It seems that tackling / challenging gender-based taboos is
at the core to improving the future for all of our future
generations.
iv) Reduce child deaths and injury prevention, particularly
in the most deprived parts of Wales where infant mortality is much
higher than the least deprived.
N/A
v) Support effective child development and emotional and social well-being specifically interventions that are delivered outside the health service which can help to detect and address developmental delays.
14)FTWW
believes it is vital that Welsh Government makes a real commitment
to supporting small third sector organisations such as ours. We are
on the ground, often run by people who have experienced the very
issues in need of tackling, with considerable expertise in doing so
effectively. We are able to see what needs doing, where, and how.
Our very nature means we are able to be immediately responsive to
need, and that we don’t have the same level of bureaucracy
which can hinder public service bodies. However, where we come
unstuck is a lack of financial resources. This means, for example,
that we are unable to replicate our services at scale. We would
urge the public sector to consider how it could collaborate more
effectively with the third sector, specifically those groups which
are based within the communities they aim to help.
15) Welsh government also needs to appreciate that temporary
contracts to deliver specific ‘projects’, as opposed to
giving organisations long-term security and the ability to grow,
evolve, and develop to suit their clients’ needs means that
projects often go undelivered (to the detriment of those requiring
them) because recruitment is a huge problem.
16) Children in particular need consistency if they’re
to cope with developmental delay and become emotionally and
socially resilient. Consistency is not possible where there is a
culture of insecurity for those responsible for supporting those
children (and their parents).
17) This also extends to primary care providers. The vast
majority of our members report fragmented, poor, and delayed care
as a result of those breakdowns in communication which come from
never seeing the same GP twice.
vi) Focus on improving learning and speech and language development through the home learning environment and access to early years’ provision (including childminders, preschools and day nurseries).
18)Support of lead carers (usually mothers) – and proper funding of third sector organisations offering emotional and practical assistance / services within the local community – should be an integral part of this.
vii) Reduce the adverse impact on the child of psychosocial issues
such as poor parenting, disruptive family relationships, domestic
violence, mental health issues and substance misuse through
effective safeguarding.
19) Challenging gender stereotypes which often mean boys
(men) don’t consider caring, nurturing and parenting as part
of their natural role needs to start being a fundamental part of
our social agenda. Similarly, for girls, empowerment is vital so
that they don’t become victims of economic and domestic abuse
and instead see themselves as equals in the world of education,
employment / earnings, and status.
20) Positive role models are essential – at home and
school – for both girls and boys. The work that the
Children’s Commissioner is doing on this (via the
‘Agenda’ programme) needs to be effectively rolled out
across all schools.
21) FTWW feels that there is too much emphasis on getting
the parent back to work as soon as the child is born. Choice is
vital and needs to be supported. Stable, high quality stay-at-home
parenting needs to be perceived as important and valuable, with the
potential to create healthy / well-rounded, resilient children in
just the same way as early years childcare, provided by external
agencies, is currently.
22) Clearly, it is time for Welsh Government to start
looking at long-term strategy, and giving ideas time to embed,
rather than fire-fighting, seeing things purely in terms of
electoral cycles, and supporting only short-term, temporary
projects.
23) This means investment is needed in those services /
strategies which have the potential to provide long-term benefit
for future generations such as mental health (with an increased
focus on maternal mental health), tackling gender-based
stereotypes, prejudice and taboos in schools and health services,
and recognising that women tend to disproportionately suffer the
consequences of poverty.
24) Welsh government should be looking to collaborate more
effectively with the third sector, including community groups, and
diverting some of its financial resources into those. Welsh
government needs to appreciate that investment in infrastructure,
to boost the economy and drive down poverty levels, does not
necessarily mean building more roads but that it can involve
investment in developing health, care, and community services
instead. Ultimately, these can make Wales more sustainable,
prosperous and fit to face the future.